CIRCA: – Valley Of The Windmill (2016)


The band consists of Tony Kaye, a former Yes member, and Billy Sherwood, who is a current member of Yes. Billy took over Chris Squire’s place as a bassist, who we sadly lost in 2015. However, mister Sherwood provides the lead vocals and guitars instead of bass on CIRCA:’s fourth album, named Valley Of The Windmill. Rick Tierney is providing the bass guitar parts, and Scott Connor does the drums and percussion.

Ok, the next question is an obvious one; Does the album sound like Yes? No… Well, not too much, in my humble opinion. I reviewed Anderson/Stolt’s Invention Of Knowledge not so long ago (you can read the review here), and that sounds a lot more like Yes than Yes has ever did the past few years. This album from CIRCA: is actually more my taste, an album which I already liked during the first spin, and the more I played it the better it even became!

The album is 52 minutes long and contains four long tracks. I’m always a bit apprehensive when it comes to long tracks. some bands try to look ‘proggy’ by making long songs, while the long songs are actually more interesting when they were shorter, and less filled up with meaningless passages purely to lubricate things together. With this album this is absolutely not the case! There are no boring moments in the tracks, everything is done well considered and fused.

First track Silent Resolve starts very ambient-like. After one minute the song changes with an organ solo, and not much later the complete band sets in. The song carries a positive and catchy vibe most of the time. The bass is very present at moments, which I quite like. After five minutes I hear a Yes influenced moment. Several musical passages and choruses that were present in the first part of the song come back from time to time, making this fifteen minute track a good prog rock song. Empire Over starts with an 80s sound, thanks to the drums and keyboard sounds. This track sounds gloomy compared to the previous one, but carries a lot of energy, and the choruses makes the song lighter in tone. The drums are vigorous and fit well in this. Title track Valley Of The Windmill is my favourite track on the album. The intro rhythm and low bass sounds very contagious. Just like Silent Resolve it carries a positive vibe. Our Place Under The Sun is with almost twenty minutes the longest track on the album. There’s a lot happening already in the first part, and you can say that there are some Yes influenced moments here and there, but not too obvious. Around six minutes the song gets more calm and retained. Some passages in the music come back from time to time, just like Silent Resolve. After twelve minutes a long instrumental piece sets in, which gets an unexpected but suprising turn after one minute. After sixteen minutes into the track the main theme of the song comes back to wrap up this long musical piece.

This album gets five out of five stars from me. A well-produced and well-fabricated album that doesn’t bore one minute and really deserves the term ‘progressive rock’. Will this album be in my top 10 list of 2016? I think it definitely  will, unless a lot of bands/artists I adore suddenly produce splendid albums before the end of the year.

***** Iris Hidding

  1. Silent Resolve (15:22)
  2. Empire Over (9:49)
  3. Valley Of The Windmill (7:52)
  4. Our Place Under The Sun (19:35)

You can listen to the track Valley Of The Windmill here:

You can also read my review on House of Prog:

You can also read my review on the website of Background Magazine:

Liked what you’ve read? Please feel free to sponsor me, so I can continue providing you interviews, reviews, stories and more fun stuff of your favourite bands and artists! Click on the ‘Donate’ button on the top left side of the page (or click on the plus on the top left side of the page when you’re reading this on your mobile device/tablet). You don’t need a PayPal account to donate! Just one dollar/euro/pound can help me a lot! Read about what happens with your donation money here. Thank you very much! 

Follow me on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube & Google +! Subscribe by entering you email address, or click on the follow button when you already have a WordPress account, so you will get my latest posts automatically in your inbox!


12 thoughts on “CIRCA: – Valley Of The Windmill (2016)

  1. Long songs have to have a certain je ne c’est quoi to them to really keep you involved in them I agree. Often I have heard a 12 minute epic that could have been summed up in 4 and others that are short that should have been stretched the length! But also not being a big Yes fan just cuz I just never got on with their sounds I’m always apprehensive in listening to anything that is a side project or related to them with former members because it all sounds the same to me, aside form the Anderson/Ponty band that’s totally left field for them and to me lol But I always consult the Great Lady Ier’s blog for these reviews and do give the albums a fair shake and listen to them as I re-look at what you have said about the songs and see if I can relate. So as always lady Ier, great review and another album for me to listen to : )

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Reblogged this on Progarchy and commented:
    I’ve had major A.D.D. lately, so it’s been difficult for me to sit through long songs, much less whole albums, but what I’ve heard so far from the new Circa album, I really dug. I’m looking forward to having a nice listen to Valley of the Windmill soon. Iris over at Grendel Headquarters has lots of great things to say about this album.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s